LIGHTHISER V. U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

On November 16, 2026, twenty-one young people from across the United States filed a petition challenging the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) repeal of a rule limiting climate pollution from fossil fuel power plants. 

The youth-led petition, Lighthiser v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, asks the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit to review and reverse EPA’s decision to eliminate most of the 2024 Carbon Pollution Standards, which were designed to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) pollution from the nation’s coal and gas power plants. The annual increase in carbon dioxide emissions resulting from EPA’s action is more than the annual energy carbon dioxide emissions from California or Australia. 

These youth join a growing number of challengers contesting the repeal, including public health and environmental organizations, and a coalition of states and cities. EPA has also proposed eliminating every remaining greenhouse gas standard for power plants, which would leave this major source of climate pollution with no federal limits at all. 

THE YOUNG PEOPLE

The petitioners are 21 young people, ages 1 to 27, from California, Colorado, Florida, Hawaiʻi, Montana, Oregon, and Wisconsin. They include Rikki Held and other young Montanans who won the landmark Held v. Montana climate case in 2023. 

Sixteen of the petitioners were plaintiffs in Lighthiser v. Trump, which challenged the Trump administration’s executive orders designed to “unleash” fossil fuels and revitalize the coal industry. In Lighthiser, the Trump administration argued that the youth could challenge each individual implementation of those executive orders separately. In June, a Ninth Circuit panel dismissed that case on standing grounds without deciding whether the orders were constitutional. The young people are now bringing a targeted challenge to one specific implementation of the executive orders by EPA that directly increases the pollution harming them. 

EPA’s action to repeal GHG limits on power plants relies explicitly on two of the executive orders challenged as unconstitutional in Lighthiser v. Trump, “Unleashing American Energy” (EO 14154) and “Reinvigorating America’s Beautiful Clean Coal Industry” (EO 14241). These executive orders directed EPA to eliminate “undue burdens on fossil fuels” and revitalize the coal industry. EPA’s final rule states that the agency “identified GHG emission standards for power plants” as one rule that must be repealed because of these executive orders, the constitutionality of which has yet to be resolved. 

Held v. Montana plaintiffs Rikki Held (right) and Eva Lighthiser (left) heading to trial.

Lighthiser v. Trump youth plaintiffs heading to court.

PROTECTING CHILDREN’S HEALTH

EPA’s own rule acknowledges that some of the health benefits of the standards it repealed would have gone to children, and that the repeal reduces those benefits. EPA moved forward anyway, saying the benefits of the standards were outweighed by their costs to the fossil fuel industry. 

The pollution EPA’s action will cause harms the petitioners’ health, threatens their safety and security, disrupts their physical and psychological growth and functioning, and ultimately violates their constitutional rights to liberty. 

CURRENT STATUS

On November 16th, 2026, Lighthiser v. EPA was filed with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. The petitioners will receive a schedule order from the court, and the case will proceed based on that established timeline. 

major moments timeline

The following is a timeline of major moments, filings, and rulings in this case, from November 2026 to today: